Week 6-7
Date: 2 March 2015
Exercise: The Essay Process (Draft 1)
In this era, data and information can be transmitted to all
over the world by just clicking the button on devices such as computer and
smart phone. This is very efficient such that the news and information are
known within a few seconds after the happening of a certain event. However, it
is questionable on the reliability of information on social media because it
might be too fast to come into a conclusion while the event is still happening,
resulting in false information. False information or misinformation refers to “
the act of giving wrong information about something”
(Oxford University Press). Although everyone
should be well-informed by the news promptly, it is crucial for the news to be
accurate.
There are a few reasons for the spreading of false
information on social media regardless intentionally or unintentionally. (Vis, 2014) states that the
reporting of breaking news is a priority for some media outlet. This might be because it can attract more
subscribers and gain more profit. As such, this causes the overlook of
time-consuming verification process; the news is published without ensuring
that it is accurate. (Hitlin, 2003) suggests that some
media outlet might intentionally release false reports to catch readers’
attraction to scandal. For example, reports that stated the crash of Trans World Airline (TWA) flight 800 was due to striking by a
missile is much more exciting and attractive than accurate reports that revealed
the technical problem in the plane as the root cause. In another case, one
might spread false information purposely to be benefited from it. (Guest, 2014) claims that
companies might propagate the messages that are able to shape the beliefs of
consumers, hence making their services or products more appealing. For example,
diet is a larger factor than lack of exercise which leads to obesity; however,
it is analysed that the 10 largest food companies in the world instil the
concept that “lack of exercise is at least as important as diet in causing
obesity”.
Misinformation is a serious problem that should be avoided, especially
on social media because it has huge impacts by reaching a large amount of
population within a short period of time. Misinformation might cause large
scale of social panic. For example, (Chandrathil, 2012) reported a rumour on
radiation leak on the border of Indiana and Michigan was spread because abnormal
level of radiation was detected by two non-governmental radiation monitoring
networks. Then, a YouTube video about the “radiation spike” had further spread
the rumour and public started to raise their concerns by flooding the related
government agencies with panicked calls. Eventually, the monitoring networks
informed the public that they were suffering from equipment malfunction hence
causing the false alarm. Apart from this, false information might be perceived
to be true once it is widely accepted, thus affecting public understanding and
knowledge. For example, the fake images and information might affect public
perceptions on certain issues, which might be favourable to parties with vested
interest.
Recently, the high number of mistakes on social media has
been discovered and it gains the attention from both authors who post the
message and the readers. To prevent the circulating of false information, it is
important for the senders and receivers to be cautious about the credibility of
the source and accuracy of the information. For example, Cable-news channel MBN
had released a live interview regarding Sewol Ferry Disaster in South Korea.
The interviewee named Hong Ga-hye, who claimed herself as private diver said
that the coast guard had stopped her from saving the survivors trapped inside
the sunken Sewol. It was later found out that Ms.Hong lied about her identity
and her argument was proven to be fallacious. Finally, the cable channel
apologised for false reporting and not checking the identity of interviewee
properly (Nam, 2014). In this case, the
source of information should be verified and the information should be double
checked between different sources such as the government agency.
In addition, author should not be biased on the reporting
issues. (Stéphanie, 2014) suggests that in the
verification process, the journalists should remove their personal emotion and also
debunk the false rumour after verification. A peer review system can be
implemented in the media outlet that requires authors to check on each other’s
reports before the reports are allowed to publish. On the other hand, readers should be aware of
false information. (Vis, 2014) believes that readers
should assume that online information is false before confirmation. They can
also cross reference to more than one source or rely on reputable publishers or
official statements from government agencies. In a nutshell, both sender and
receiver are responsible to avoid circulation of untrue messages and
information.
In conclusion, the internet is a powerful tool which makes
the world become borderless. Internet users have been inundated with news and information and it
becomes challenging to determine the information that can be trusted. To solve
this problem, authors should be conscious and ethical to convey solid
information while readers should interpret and
check the reliability of the message before accepting it as a fact.
References
Chandrathil, P.
(2012, June 19). Radioactive Rumor Mill Doesn’t Help Anyone. Retrieved
February 23, 2015, from U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission:
http://public-blog.nrc-gateway.gov/2012/06/19/radioactive-rumor-mill-doesnt-help-anyone/
Guest, G. (2014,
June 26). Lean-washing: Profiting from misinformation on what causes
obesity. Retrieved February 23, 2015, from Michigan News:
http://ns.umich.edu/new/releases/22264-lean-washing-profiting-from-misinformation-on-what-causes-obesity
Hitlin, P. (2003).
False Reporting on the Internet and the Spread of Rumors: Three Case
Studies. Retrieved February 23, 2015, from Gnovis Journal:
http://www.gnovisjournal.org/files/Paul-Hitlin-False-Reporting-on-the-Internet.pdf
Lux, A. (2008,
December 12). Spread of false information causes dangers, says Sunstein.
Retrieved February 23, 2015, from HAVARD LAW Today: http://today.law.harvard.edu/spread-of-false-information-causes-dangers-says-sunstein/
Nam, I.-S. (2014,
May 16). Media Outlets Apologize Over Sewol Ferry Disaster Coverage.
Retrieved February 23, 2015, from The Wall Street Journal:
http://blogs.wsj.com/korearealtime/2014/05/16/media-outlets-apologize-over-sewol-ferry-disaster-coverage/
Oxford University
Press. (n.d.). misinformation. Retrieved February 23, 2015, from Oxford
Learner's Dictionaries:
http://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/definition/english/misinformation?q=misinformation
Stéphanie, D.
(2014). Case Study 1.1: Separating Rumor From Fact in a Nigerian Conflict
Zone. Retrieved February 23, 2015, from Verification Handbook:
http://verificationhandbook.com/book/chapter1.1.php
Vis, F. (2014,
April 16). How Does False Information Spread Online? Retrieved February
23, 2015, from social science space:
http://www.socialsciencespace.com/2014/04/how-does-false-information-spread-online/